Written by @VisualTejeda

November 24, 2024 | 6:40 PM

The San Diego Padres have reached a pivotal moment in franchise history. After a season filled with promise and a deep postseason run, the 2024-2025 offseason is shaping up as a make-or-break opportunity for general manager AJ Preller. Known for his aggressive approach to building a roster, Preller faces the monumental task of constructing a World Series-winning team while navigating financial constraints and key player decisions.

Preller’s legacy has been defined by blockbuster trades, marquee signings, and bold risks. However, this offseason is about more than star power—it’s about achieving balance and delivering results. With a talented but crowded and expensive roster, the Padres must address gaps, reconfigure positions, and make tough calls that could either propel them to glory or lead to a dead end.

Infield Crowding and Tough Decisions

The Padres’ infield is loaded with talent, yet it’s also a source of pressing questions. Ha-Seong Kim’s likely departure following his decision to decline a mutual option leaves the team with a hole at second base and an opportunity to realign their star-studded lineup.

Xander Bogaerts Back to Shortstop

Bogaerts, who shifted to second base last season to accommodate Kim, is expected to return to his natural position at shortstop. This move solidifies the left side of the infield but creates ripple effects throughout the roster.

Jake Cronenworth’s Versatility

Cronenworth remains a valuable asset due to his defensive flexibility, but his offensive decline in 2024 raises questions about his future. While his $80 million contract provides stability, it could also make him a trade candidate. Moving Cronenworth would free up payroll and allow for other acquisitions, but finding a partner for a deal might be challenging.

Luis Arráez: DH or Second Base?

The 2024 batting champion has been a catalyst offensively, but his defensive limitations complicate his role. As a designated hitter, Arráez brings consistency to the lineup, but if the Padres keep him in the infield, it could further crowd the roster. Deciding where Arráez fits will shape the rest of the lineup.

The Outfield Dilemma

The emergence of Jackson Merrill as the team’s center fielder provides stability, but questions remain in left field. Jurickson Profar, fresh off a career-best season, is now a free agent, and re-signing him would come at a premium. With Scott Boras as his agent, Profar’s price tag may be too high for the Padres’ budget.

Instead, the team may need to explore cost-effective free-agent options or even shift players like Cronenworth to the outfield to fill the gap. Merrill’s rise has created flexibility, but the Padres still need a reliable left fielder to complement Fernando Tatis Jr. in right field.

The Need for a Power-Hitting First Baseman

A glaring need for the Padres is a power-hitting first baseman. If Cronenworth is traded or moved to another position, the Padres could target big names like Pete Alonso or Christian Walker. Adding a premier bat at first base would address the team’s offensive inconsistencies but could also force Preller to part with prospects or make other trades to balance the roster.

Pitching Depth and Bullpen Reinforcements

Joe Musgrove’s absence due to Tommy John surgery leaves a hole in the rotation. The Padres have promising arms in the minors, such as Victor Lizarraga and Bradgley Rodriguez, who could step up. However, relying solely on prospects is a risk. Adding a veteran starter and a reliable left-handed setup man will be crucial to fortifying the pitching staff.

AJ Preller’s World Series Mandate

AJ Preller’s tenure in San Diego has been defined by bold moves and high expectations. This offseason is about proving that his aggressive strategies can lead to a championship. With cornerstone players like Manny Machado, Xander Bogaerts, and Fernando Tatis Jr. in their primes, and rising stars like Jackson Merrill ready to shine, the time to win is now.

The Padres’ postseason performance has shown their potential to compete at the highest level. To turn that potential into a championship, Preller must make smart, calculated moves. Whether it’s adding a power bat, reconfiguring the infield, or bolstering the pitching staff, this offseason is Preller’s chance to deliver the elusive World Series title.

A Season of Destiny?

There’s a sense of destiny surrounding this offseason. With a mix of proven stars and emerging talent, the Padres have the pieces to contend. Now, it’s up to Preller to make the right moves to bring everything together.

If he succeeds, AJ Preller will cement his place in San Diego sports history as the architect of the Padres’ greatest team. If he falls short, his legacy will be one of unfulfilled promise.

For more in-depth coverage, exclusive insights, and the latest Padres updates, keep it locked on FriarPulse—where the heartbeat of San Diego baseball thrives. Stay connected, Friar faithful!